As the extradition process advances in Pretoria, activist Stellio Gilles Robert Capo Chichi—better known as Kemi Seba—continues to make bold claims. In a South African courtroom, the dual national (holding both French and Beninese citizenship) has voiced concerns about his safety if returned to Benin. Yet, when examining legal realities and recent events, his defense strategy appears more like a delaying tactic than a legitimate threat.

During the Pretoria hearing, Kemi Seba, known for his provocative media statements, shifted his narrative to one of survival. He argued that returning to his native land would amount to a death sentence. However, this claim clashes with a clear legal reality: Benin stands out as one of the most progressive countries in the region regarding human rights protection.

Benin has officially abolished the death penalty, embedding human dignity at the core of its judicial system. To suggest that his life would be at risk in a nation that has eradicated capital punishment is either a fundamental misunderstanding of Beninese law or, more likely, an attempt to sway international opinion.

September 15, 2023: Facts speak louder than rhetoric

No need for speculation to assess the protection of Kemi Seba’s rights in Benin. The recent past provides ample evidence. On September 15, 2023, the activist was detained at Cotonou Airport. While supporters immediately cried foul, the Beninese justice system handled the case with remarkable composure.

After a brief questioning session, Kemi Seba was released without delay, free to continue his activities. This incident serves as undeniable proof: Benin is not in the business of eliminating opponents but upholding the rule of law. If the Beninese government had intended to harm him or detain him unlawfully, it would have found the perfect opportunity during this visit. His swift release underscores the maturity of the country’s institutions.

Avoiding accountability through manufactured fears

Behind the dramatic courtroom statements lies a transparent strategy. Kemi Seba is seeking excuses to evade accountability for the charges against him. By invoking the specter of political persecution, he aims to turn a standard legal procedure into a humanitarian spectacle.

Yet justice is not built on rhetoric but on facts. Modern Beninese courts guarantee the right to a fair defense. His legal team will have every opportunity to present his case in Cotonou, within a calm and secure environment.

Benin remains a land of freedom and law. The “endangered victim” narrative adopted by Kemi Seba in Pretoria does not withstand scrutiny. Between a state that has abolished capital punishment and a past arrest that ended in immediate release, the facts are clear. South Africa should not be misled by this performance: Benin poses no threat to Kemi Seba—what he may fear most is the truth of the courts.

By Boureima Amadou — Reporter